How “Flash Sales Fatigue” is transforming a 13 year-old concept

First a little bit of context and history:

The online Flash Sales model was invented in France in 2001 to work around a law preventing resellers to do clearance sales outside of the government prescribed windows. There are loopholes in that law and that is why Flash Sales were invented. Before Flash Sales were online, The group of partners that founded vente-privee.com, already had a monopoly on overstock business in Europe. They leveraged on all traditional channels to get rid of overstock from the well-known brands that trusted them already for 15 years. They were used to split the overstock into smaller lots and sold it to low-cost stores. Later, they started using showrooms that became very successful. The founders were constrained by their walls and they quickly understood that growth for their highly discounted overstock business could only work through maintaining low infrastructure costs, moving more inventory at higher velocity and finding a way to not damage the brands’ images so the already long-lasting partnership could be maintained. Flash Sales were born because they addressed three original motivations:

  1. It needed to be a private sale addressing only a subset of the population (Hence the login gate)
  2. There needed to be a very high discount to justify a 14 days delivery time and negative cash flow requirements of the model essentially based on post-sale consignment and where sales are only made out of samples and promises of stock.
  3. It needed to last for a very limited time to create the sentiment of urgency (Hence the term Flash Sales)

This way of getting rid of overstock became a very intuitive and easy way for brands to start having an online presence and it spiraled into brands in Europe becoming Lazy in their sourcing and storage strategy because vente-privee.com and the Flash Sales model in general in Europe has been for the last 13 years a very efficient insurance policy against risks of stock.

As the inventor of the concept, vente-privee.com became a trusted shopping destination for an entire generation of new Internet Users new to ecommerce. This monopoly in France is not fainting and the daily traffic of the website allows the founders, still privately heading the company’s destiny today, to extend their offer with travels, wine, daily deals, last-minute show ticket and more recently gourmet food.

Vente-privee was the first, and was already profitable in 2004 and the tremendous growth and success fueled their european expansion and strengthened their monopoly. They succeeded because:

  1. They were a monopoly before getting online
  2. They focused on owning their entire value-chain right from the start from Digital production to Fulfillment and Customer Services inventing a new operations model every time
  3. They focused on being a B2B2C company focusing mainly on being a solution for brands considering designers and brands as their main customer and by putting member or consumer lower in their list of priorities. (The essence of the success of all supply-driven companies)
  4. They managed to preserve the image of the brands with beautiful photography sometimes giving a second life to aged inventory and often doing an even better marketing and merchandizing job than the brand itself
  5. They created long-term partnerships favoring brands in performing repeat events twice a year or even every quarter sometimes.

But now it is obvious that the business model reached a plateau and the game is changing: 

It is a true statement to say that the traditional motivations behind Flash Sales in Europe has plateaued. There is a limit in the number of brands that can be featured in one day and the 20% YoY growth of vente-privee.com since 2010 is due to the vision they had back then to exploit the 3 Million unique visitors landing on their sites every day to sell them tickets, travels, food, one-day deals, groupon-like offers, wine, etc. When the traffic is there and when the trust remains, an online company is unstoppable and can only grow. The biggest challenge that vente-privee.com never tackled because they never had to is the improvement of their sell-through. The average sell-through of an event has remained steady around in the past years. They never got to implementing strategies around personalization, up-selling, cross-selling or dynamic search that would have allowed them to get rid of the stereotype that everything gets sold in the first hour of a sale which is obviously a wrong assumption. But this perception contributed to a phenomenon I would call “Flash Sales fatigue”

vente-privee.com remains highly dependent on the quality of the stock brands carry. They experienced it the hard way in 2009-2010 where their struggle to source a quality offer triggered the exploration of all those alternative verticals that were enumerated earlier. As the world gets smarter and as big data enables for more efficiency, better tuned sourcing strategies and tighter understanding of markets will see brand’s needs for overstock management solutions fade away as time goes by. This is a logic requirement to the survival of brands against the Asian brand tsunami currently in the making. Once this revolution materializes, one of the only edges that our designers and brands will preserve is their deep roots in our history (Levi’s, Chanel, Dior, Louis Vuitton, Van Cleef and Arpels etc. appeal to multiple generations and became timeless) Unless brands remain lazy and tackle other problems of their backlog before this one as long as they have the Flash Sales solution.

Flash Sales fatigue in the US?:

When the Flash Sales model moved to the United States in 2007, the game rules of Flash Sales were not used to solve the same overstock problems. It was used to offer a different shopping experience, play with the sentiment of urgency, dynamically manage fast moving limited inventories, and showcase discount in a refreshing way. The exclusive consignment model was abandoned very early by the US early Flash Sales adopters Rue La La and GILT. Americans, already expecting shorter delivery times, have a very distinct vision and exposure to discount as deals are pervasive on both the web and brick-and-mortar models. The reason why Flash Sales worked in the US is the reason why they still survive today: They evolved into a curation method and members of the Flash Sales ecosystem trust that what is being proposed is relevant to what they look for (Designers, Brands, Categories, price points, colors , styles). The fatigue for this online shopping approach flows from the fact that it sees the same unsold merchandise being re-ran perpetually. It also damages the brands that become reluctant to such practices. Vente-privee USA launched in 2011 with the clear intention to come and do it right and attempt to re-focus the market on the consignment model but is clearly failing to do so because there are many more well-established solutions in the market executing better.

Flash Sales as a curation method is here to stay because of the trust relationship established between the curator and the members. It lives side-by-side with search and personalization.

Flash Sales as a method to liquidate overstock is losing traction and efficiency. Mostly because of a lack of focus and an increasing will from all existing actors to diversify their offer and leverage on their traffic to increase revenue.

Flash Sales The RealReal way are here to stay?

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s